Judge Philosophies

ANDREW PEPPERS - LAC

n/a


Aadarsha Kunwar (he/him) - USM

n/a


Abraham Cardona - Patriot Debate

n/a


Adam LoBaido - GCU

n/a


Addison Jacobsen - LSUS

n/a


Addison Suwarow - MSU

n/a


Addison Wenz - UNG

n/a


Adrienne Davis - LSUS

n/a


Akshara Muruganandam - UARK

n/a


Alex Bourgeois - LSUS

n/a


Andrew Simpson - UU

n/a


Andria Feraci - MSU

n/a


Angelina Larosa - UCSD

n/a


Angie Quiroz Ordonez* - ACU

n/a


Anitra Fayad - LSUS

n/a


Anna Hinman - MSU

n/a


Anthony McMullen (he/him) - UCA

Experience
I competed in IPDA for the University of Arkansas (20002005) and have coached at the University of Central Arkansas since 2007. Most of my experience is in IPDA, and that shapes how I evaluate rounds. Im also a licensed attorney and spent seven years working for the Arkansas Court of Appeals, where my job was to evaluate arguments with real-world consequences. I consider myself a policymaker judge, which means I approach the round as if Im deciding whether the resolution should be adopted in the real world based on its practical merits.

General Philosophy
I strongly prefer to decide rounds on the merits of the resolution. However, if a debater shows that fairness or structure has been meaningfully compromised, I will evaluate theory or procedural argumentsbut the bar is high. Theory arguments must be clearly structured (interpretation, violation, standards, and voters) and well explained. I default to reasonability over competing interpretations and expect to see real, round-specific abuse rather than abstract or hypothetical violations. One conditional advocacy is fine by default, but multiple conditional worlds require strong justification. If theory restores fairness or protects the structure of the round, Ill vote on it. If it feels like a technical trap, I wont.

Impact Calculus and Rebuttals
Final speeches should focus on impact calculus. Dont just extend your argumentscompare them. Tell me why your impacts matter more. If you're arguing that your world is bigger, faster, more probable, or more ethical, make that analysis explicit.

No new arguments in rebuttals. You may extend previous claims and bring in additional evidence to support them, but entirely new arguments or impacts introduced for the first time in the final speech will not be considered.

Delivery and Organization
Speed hurts more than it helps. Think podcast at 1.5x speedthats about as fast as I can comfortably process. I wont vote on what I cant understand, and in forms of debate that discourse speed and spreading, I will penalize it even if I catch everything. Id much rather hear three strong, developed arguments than six rushed ones.

I do flow the round, but I care more about clarity, structure, and impact comparison than technical line-by-line coverage. Pointing out that your opponent dropped an argument is fine, but that by itself wont win the round on its own. You must explain why that dropped argument matters within the broader context of the debate.

Framework and Evaluation
Weighing mechanisms are not required. If you think one helps you frame the round, feel free to offer it. If not, I will default to a preponderance of the evidence standardwhichever side provides the more persuasive and well-supported world should win.

Cross-Ex and POIs
I listen to cross-examination and Points of Information and consider them part of the round. However, these tools are most effective when used to set up your next speech. If you get a key concession or back your opponent into a corner, make sure you follow up on it and tell me why it matters.

Topicality and Disclosure
I will vote on topicality when it is well explained and clearly tied to fairness or ground loss. I give the affirmative the benefit of the doubt when their interpretation aligns with framers intent. If the resolution is straightforward, no disclosure is required. If the resolution is metaphorical or unusually vague, disclosure is encouraged. While I wont penalize a team for failing to disclose, I willdisqualify a team for giving a false or misleading disclosure.

Kritiks
I am open to kritiks, but dont assume Im fluent in the literature. Please walk me through the link, impact, and alternative in clear, accessible language. Im more receptive to kritiks that challenge real-world assumptions or harms than to those that only critique debate as an institution. While I still prefer to vote on the merits of the resolution, I will evaluate a K if it is well-developed and contextualized within the round.

Evidence
I value quality over quantity. A well-explained statistic or quotation is more persuasive than a long string of uncontextualized data. Paraphrased evidence is fine as long as it is accurate and clearly connected to your claims.

Professionalism and Courtesy
Debate is a competitive activity, but it should also be respectful. You dont need to thank me profusely or perform gratitude, but I do expect debaters to treat each other with courtesy. Rudeness, sarcasm, or dismissiveness toward your opponent will hurt your speaker points and my impression of your argumentation.

Humor is welcome when appropriate. If the topic is lighthearted, a well-timed joke or clever phrasing can enhance your presentation. Just keep it respectful, and dont let humor become a substitute for substance.

Final Thought
Your job is to help me write a ballot. I appreciate smart choices, organized thinking, and meaningful clash. Help me understand your advocacy, show me why its preferable, and do so with clarity, strategy, and respect.


Anthony Diaz - MSU

n/a


Aracely Tobias - UCSD

n/a


Ariel Sepulvado - LSUS

n/a


Aryanna Morales - UCSD

n/a


Aviel Guitzkow - ACU

n/a


Ayan Chokshi - UNG

n/a


Azzam Zeidan - LSUS

n/a


Bailey Vacca - Patriot Debate

n/a


Ben Janssen - Harding

n/a


Blaine Haywood - MSU

n/a


Brady Super - UARK

n/a


Braeden Helmick - UU

n/a


Brandon Knight - WmCarey

Compete with dignity.


Brandy Quintero Mendez - UU

n/a


Braydon Fontenot - LSUS

n/a


Braylon Stringer - LSUS

n/a


Brody Mercer - ACU

n/a


CJ Miller - UCMO

n/a


CJ Longino - LSUS

n/a


Caitlin Cole - LSUS

n/a


Caleb McCurren - MurSta

n/a


Cameron Thoele - LSUS

n/a


Carley Perry - NSU

n/a


Carson Hyde - LSUS

n/a


Cas Schnell - LSUS

n/a


Cav Szott - ATU

n/a


Celso Defreitas - LSUS

n/a


Celucien Joseph - LSUS

n/a


Chamiru Dewundaraliyanawaduge - UCSD

n/a


Clayton Winters - WmCarey

n/a


Cody Festerman - LSUS

n/a


Cole Fairchild - MSU

n/a


Conner Morrow - WmCarey

n/a


Cyra Pratt - LSUS

n/a


Daisy Murfey - UU

n/a


Daniel Spatzierath - LSUS

n/a


Daniel Jones - LSUS

n/a


Darius Chargois - LSUS

n/a


David Gaither - LSUS

n/a


Deerga Ramu - UARK

n/a


Devesh Sarda - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Alycia Cole - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Basak Kavakli - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Elisabeth Liebert - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Kathy Pollock - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Kristie Weeks - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Laura Meiki - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Robert Alford - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Tibor Szarvas - LSUS

n/a


Dr. Zeeshan Noor - LSUS

n/a


Elijah Hawk - Harding

n/a


Elizabeth Orton - MSU

n/a


Ella Grannon - UARK

n/a


Emily Dowd (they/them) - LSUS

n/a


Emily Schnell - LSUS

n/a


Emily Adams - UU

n/a


Emma Jaramillo - MSU

n/a


Erika Brooks - LSUS

n/a


Evan Garrison - MSU

n/a


Faith Atwater - UU

n/a


Frances Jones - LSUS

n/a


Gavin Claprood - UCSD

n/a


Giana Ferrero - UCSD

n/a


Grace Welshans - LSUS

n/a


Grant Bonin - LSUS

n/a


Gretta Graves (she/her) - USM

n/a


Gursimar Kaur - UCSD

n/a


Gwen Drozal - UCA

n/a


Hailey Meshew - MurSta

n/a


Hailey Parker - UU

n/a


Hamilton Gibbs - ACU

n/a


Hannah Ross - LSUS

n/a


Hannah Stanton - Patriot Debate

n/a


Hannah Barnett - ACU

n/a


Hayden Jescheling - UARK

n/a


Hope Oglesby - Patriot Debate

n/a


Isabella Zuniga - ATU

n/a


Isabelle Leber - UCSD

n/a


Isak Schmidley - LSUS

n/a


Isom Gerty - UU

n/a


Izzy Mejia-Aveledo - UU

n/a


JULIETTE ESLAYED - LAC

n/a


Ja'i Dantzler - UCA

n/a


Jace Godfrey (He/Him) - UARK

n/a


Jaci Sabatini (They/Them) - UARK

n/a


Jack Van Dyke (He/They) - UARK

n/a


Jack Snyder - MSU

n/a


Jackie Garcia-Torres - ACU

n/a


Jackson Evans - UCSD

n/a


Jackson Olson - NSU

n/a


Jackson Csoma* - ACU

n/a


Jacob Trosclair - MSU

n/a


Jacob Russell - ATU

n/a


Jacob Roark - MSU

n/a


Jacob Neal - MSU

n/a


Jaidon Simmons - LSUS

n/a


Jake Leckrone - UU

n/a


Jalyn Childers - ACU

n/a


James Crews - USM

n/a


Jasmine Forck - LSUS

n/a


Jasper Millsaps - ATU

n/a


Jayden Kennedy - GCU

n/a


Jayden Kennedy - USM

n/a


Jayla James - Patriot Debate

n/a


Jaylen Terrell - LSUS

n/a


Jeff Peterson - GCU

n/a


Jessica Lescher - LSUS

n/a


Jewel Thomas - LSUS

n/a


Jocelyn Garcia Torres - ACU

n/a


Joey Beeks - LSUS

n/a


John Brown - LSUS

n/a


John Holaday - MSU

n/a


Johnathan Woodall - SMU

n/a


Johnnie Sullivan - Patriot Debate

n/a


Jordan Compton - UCMO

n/a


Jordy Wasleski - UCMO

n/a


Josephine Moore - LSUS

n/a


Joshua Tripp - ATU

n/a


Josue Morales - Harding

n/a


Julian Mackenzie - UCSD

Note:This is all for guidance on what I would like to see. At the end of the day have the debate you want to have, and I will do my best to evaluate it.

Background:Hi my name is Julian Mackenzie, I participated in Speech and Debate for a total of 9 years as a competitor and now I'm a Coach for SDSU.

  1. In high school. I competed for four years in mostly Interp, Extemp, Impromptu, LD, and Pufo for Helix Charter High School. In my senior year, I was a debate captain for my high school team.
  2. I competed for two years for the Grossmont Community College team in NPDA, IPDA and Extemp, where I won top competitor for the 2021-2022 school year.
  3. After that I competed for UCSD for three years in NPDA, IPDA, Pufo, and TIPDA, and I was the President of the team.
  4. Now I Coach and I am the Director of Debate and Limited Prep at San Diego State University. In addition I am also a assistant coach at UCSD.

All formats:

  1. I like Lay debate or fast and Technical debate.
  2. I will take any argument into consideration as long as the argument is backed up by logic or evidence.
  3. Both teams/competitors in your last speech please give me clear voters, so that I can make an informed decision.
  4. Have good clash
  5. Please signpost
  6. Please be as organized as possible tell me exactly where you are on the flow.
  7. Please be respectful to everyone in the round.
  8. Have Fun!

IPDA:

  1. I prefer tech over truth, but I will not accept arguments that are a lie and do not have evidence or some truth.
  2. Present strong, logical, cohesive arguments.
  3. Please speak with a clear and calm pace.
  4. Label each of your arguments.
  5. Avoid technical debate jargon.
  6. Keep Cases and arguments simple and clear

NPDA:

  1. I'm ok with theory/topicality but I think it has to be warranted.
  2. I'll vote on a RVI including time skew.
  3. I love Value and Fact rounds, so please do not define a round as policy if it does not have should in the resolution.
  4. K's work in Policy Rounds, run Phil if it's a value round.

NFA-LD:

  1. Run a good and sound plan
  2. Tricks are great, but please keep them at the top of the case.
  3. I'm ok with theory/topicality but I think it has to be warranted.
  4. I'll vote on a RVI including time skew.
  5. Share your doc with me if you are going to spread, please.
  6. Please have your card doc ready to show your opponent's cards

Speech:

  1. As for speech I judge like any other speech judge on content and performance.
  2. Please do not "can" your speech in Impromptu. If I find your "canning" I will place any off-the-cuff speech ahead of you.
  3. I will not automatically rank you lower if your speech is shorter than 10 minutes.


Julissia Benejan - LSUS

n/a


Justina Vigarra - MSU

n/a


Jyoti Aggarwal - LSUS

n/a


Kaelyn Richard - LAC

n/a


Kamron Hitson - MSU

n/a


Karla Howell - NSU

n/a


Kate Rutherford - UU

n/a


Katie Rittenberg - UCSD

n/a


Katy Cumpton - USM

n/a


Kayla Venable - LSUS

n/a


Keith Milstead - SMU


Kevin Colorado - UCSD

n/a


Kolten Lope (He/him) - BPCC

n/a


LANA JOLLY - LAC

n/a


LCU-Noel Martin - LAC

n/a


LCU-Ruby Gross - LAC

n/a


Larry Gariepy - MSU

n/a


Lauren Carpenter - ATU

n/a


Lauren Williams - LSUS

n/a


Levi Cook - Patriot Debate

n/a


Levi Grubbs - LSUS

n/a


Lexi Martin - WmCarey

n/a


Liam Boardwine - MurSta

n/a


Liam Nicholason - MSU

n/a


Lindsay Duede - LSUS

n/a


Lindsey Brown - LSUS

n/a


Lizeth Andraca - LSUS

n/a


Luke Fitzsimmons - UCMO

n/a


Mack Miles (They/Them) - LSUS

n/a


Madeline McClatchey - LSUS

n/a


Makenzie Barger - MSU

n/a


Mandi Cumpton - USM

n/a


Mario Rodriguez - LSUS

n/a


Marisa Connell - LSUS

n/a


Matthew Cook (He/Him) - UARK

n/a


Matthew Cornealious - LSUS

n/a


Mav Holloway - LSUS

n/a


Maverick Alsobrook - LSUS

n/a


Max DeCosta - ATU

n/a


Medhawi Chaulagain - LSUS

n/a


Mia Denner - WmCarey

n/a


Micah McGee - UU

n/a


Michael McDonnell - UU

n/a


Michael Green - MSU

n/a


Mollie Champlin - LSUS

n/a


Munal Baniya - LSUS

n/a


Nadia Reinschmiedt - LSUS

n/a


Natalie Cottrell - LSUS

n/a


Natasha Gamboa - UCSD

n/a


NeVeya Mitchell - LSUS

n/a


Nevaeh Leanord - MSU

n/a


Nicholas Madison - WmCarey

n/a


Nicolas Hrechko - LSUS

n/a


Olivia Buhler - UCSD

n/a


Owen McGinty - LSUS

n/a


Param Thakkar - LSUS

n/a


Percy Blaich (He/Him) - UARK

n/a


Peyton Amicone - UU

n/a


Phillip Parker - NSU

n/a


Phoenix Cao - MSU

n/a


Presleigh McLemore - MSU

n/a


Ria Christian - Patriot Debate

n/a


Riley Lewis - LSUS

n/a


Robert Toledo - LSUS

n/a


Robert Bailey - LSUS

n/a


Rylee Mahon - ACU

n/a


Sabrina Duff - LSUS

n/a


Sage Ezell - LSUS

n/a


Sage Ross - ATU

n/a


Sal Abdelkader - UARK

n/a


Sal Abdelkader - UARK

n/a


Sam Harvey - MSU

n/a


Sarah Youngblood - LSUS

n/a


Sarah Flores - SMU

n/a


Sev Rieke - MSU

n/a


Shanisha Ford (She/Her) - LSUS

n/a


Shelby Cumpton (she/her) - USM

n/a


Sheree Toms - USM

n/a


Sidney Adams - UARK

n/a


Simon Vos - LSUS

n/a


Skylee Hartley - ATU

n/a


Sophie Katcher - UCMO

n/a


Stephania Ortez - UNG

n/a


Stephanie Yeh - UCSD

Stephanie Yeh

Background - I started debating in 5th grade and have competed across multiple different formats - NSDA Modified Parli, HS Parli, HS Public Forum, some CEDA, NFA-LD, NPDA, and IPDA. I have coached and judged for most of these as well with some experience with judging Worlds and BP. I'm familiar with carded debate and prefer using SpeechDrop.net over email when possible.

Paradigm - In general, I will vote on pretty much anything. I am a heavy flow judge and utilize multiple sheets to organize arguments. As such, I prefer off time roadmaps, except in IPDA. On case, I look for stock issues to be addressed and look for offensive responses.In regards to DAs/CPs, I love them. This is my bread and butter but please do not run linear DAs. CPs should be functionally/textually competitive as I do believe that perms are a strong aff strat. PICs are fine. On T shells, I enjoy them and believe they are strong arguments but typically want proven abuse arguments to vote on them - this is particularly true for any Monocot/Tricot theories. I've voted on RVIs before but they have to be exceptionally articulated. For Ks/Phil, I'm happy to hear them and actually find them particularly fun to judge but I do need strong links to the res and some form of RoB/RoJ. I am familiar with some lit but please provide some explanation/background for both me and your opponents. Of note, I am particularly sensitive to using identity/culture/race-based/gender Ks as a debate strategy rather than an advocacy and emphasize that these are incredibly sensitive and personal topics that should not be gamified.

Speaking - I am good with speed if it is clear. If your opponents call clear or speed, please make a noticeable effort to accommodate. SIGNPOSTING IS VERY IMPORTANT TO ME, if I don't know where you are, this is when I start not flowing arguments.

I am always happy to answer any questions in round if needed and will always provide feedback if you run into me throughout the tournament.


Steve Lesher - LSUS

n/a


Sydney Crank - UCMO

n/a


Tamara Bojanic - LSUS

n/a


Tanner Brown - LSUS

n/a


Taris Cooper - LSUS

n/a


Thomas Thurner - MSU

n/a


Trey Gibson - LSUS

n/a


Trishunda Smith - LSUS

n/a


Tyler Wilhite - LSUS

n/a


Tyler Lafayette - UARK

n/a


Tyron rhodesss - USM

n/a


Valentina Osario - UNG

n/a


Vanessa LeDay - LSUS

n/a


Vivian Wang - UARK

n/a


Wyatt Logue - ATU

n/a


Zach Posey - LSUS

n/a


Zenobia Bowlin - LSUS

n/a


Zoey Weeks - UCA

n/a