2016 Logan Will Ultimate Challenge
Grants Pass/North Valley - Jan 29-30 | Status: Completed
Judge Philosophies
Alexander Johnson - Grants Pass
n/a
Alicia Romo - Grants Pass
n/a
Ann Willing - Grants Pass
n/a
Anna Willing - Grants Pass
n/a
Ben Knobel - Coquille
n/a
Bo Alderton - Grants Pass
n/a
Bob Putney - Grants Pass
n/a
Brad Berdelman - South Medford
n/a
Brian Hampton - Marshfield HS
n/a
Caroline Campbell - South Medford
n/a
Catherine Hampton - Marshfield HS
n/a
Celia Johnson - NMHS
n/a
Coleman Antintcie - Grants Pass
n/a
Colton Duval - Grants Pass
n/a
Coz Costintino - Grants Pass
n/a
Cyndi Fortuna - Grants Pass
n/a
Danielle Atkinson - South Medford
n/a
David Wood - Grants Pass
n/a
Dennis Will - Grants Pass
n/a
Deonne Wright - Grants Pass
n/a
Diana Traylor - Grants Pass
n/a
Diane Frank - Bandon HS
n/a
Ellen Howard - Bandon HS
n/a
Emily Madden - Grants Pass
n/a
Frank Mukaida - Marshfield HS
n/a
Grace Warner - South Medford
n/a
Heather Woodruff - N Val
n/a
Jana Jordaan - South Medford
n/a
Janet Capetty - Grants Pass
n/a
Jennifer Wagner - IVHS
n/a
Jennifer Roberts - Grants Pass
n/a
Jim Whittington - South Medford
n/a
Joanne Costintino - Grants Pass
n/a
Jody Thomas - Grants Pass
n/a
John Stump - Cleveland
John Atkins - Grants Pass
n/a
John Jessup - Grants Pass
n/a
Josh Scheirman - Marshfield HS
n/a
Julie Hagstrom - South Medford
n/a
Kalin Cross - South Medford
n/a
Kara Blake - Butte Falls
n/a
Katherine Hernandez - South Medford
n/a
Kayla Crook - Marshfield HS
n/a
Keith Eddins - Oak Hill
<p>I prefer and default to a policymaker paradigm in CX policy debate. In current jargon, I reside in the truth-over-tech world. That said, I try to evaluate the round from (almost) any framework on which the debaters agree. If they cannot or do not agree, I will do my best to adjudicate the framework issue, as well, based on the arguments presented in the round. Regardless, I believe AFF cases should have a plan, not just a generalized statement of intent. I still consider inherency an issue that must be addressed by the AFF, and I think solvency should be demonstrated in the 1AC. In my mind, the notion of presumption favoring the status quo (and, thus, the NEG) continues to exist. That said, if AFF presents a prima facie case and NEG chooses not to contest it, presumption essentially shifts to AFF, and NEG better have some pretty persuasive off-case positions. I am liberal on T (at least from an affirmative perspective). But if NEG presents a strong T argument that AFF fails to rebut effectively, I will treat T as an a priori voting issue. In NEG terms, a well-constructed, logical, evidence-based DISAD remains the most persuasive argument against an AFF plan. It need not result in nuclear war or the end of the world. In fact, I find most DISADs more persuasive when not taken to the ultimate extreme. Ks are fine arguments provided you really understand and explain them. But you need to present them in terms I can understand; while I know my Marx, Engels, and Lenin quite well, I would never even pretend to comprehend French post-modernist philosophy (to use one example). CPs should offer sufficient detail to be fully evaluated and include evidence-based solvency arguments. As for other forms of debate, I will gladly evaluate an LD round from either a value or policy perspective depending on the nature of the resolution and the results of any framework debate. Plans, Ks, and CPs are fine in LD. In Parli, I am also quite comfortable with plans, Ks, and CPs, but they are not necessary. However, I will discount arguments in Parli that are based on a gross factual misstatement (even if the other team fails to challenge it). In Public Forum, I am looking for solid evidence-based argumentation and real clash (too often the clash is missing in PF debate). In each of these forms of debate I am a flow judge. But for me to flow your arguments effectively, I need good signposting and clearly stated tag lines. Remember: I neither receive nor do I want a flashed version of your speech. Your best arguments may prove meaningless if you fail to tell me where to record them on the flow.</p>
Lana Tolls - Grants Pass
n/a
Lana Toll - Grants Pass
n/a
Lance Haberly - Siuslaw High
n/a
Laurie Putney - Grants Pass
n/a
Luke Kuydendall - Butte Falls
n/a
Lydia Casas - Marshfield HS
n/a
Marina Whitchurch - Grants Pass
n/a
Mark Stueve - Marshfield HS
n/a
Matthew Eldridge - Butte Falls
n/a
Matthew Parker - South Medford
n/a
Melodie Martz - N Val
n/a
Miles Stirewalt - Willamette
n/a
Nichole Barber - NMHS
n/a
Nick Davis - Grants Pass
n/a
Nick Gragg - N Val
n/a
Pam Hardy - Grants Pass
n/a
Patrick Gonzales - Cleveland
Paul Fairman - N Val
n/a
Ronnie Kendrick - Grants Pass
n/a
Stephanie Wilson - Grants Pass
n/a
Tammy Tomlinson - Grants Pass
n/a
Tracy Wilhelm - Grants Pass
n/a
Tracy Muday - Marshfield HS
n/a
Tyler Curtis - Bandon HS
n/a
Virginia Richardson - Grants Pass
n/a