Judge Philosophies
Abbie Vandervoort - Boise High
n/a
Adam Nunnally - Hunger Hired
n/a
Al Stout - Skyview
n/a
Alex Belisle - Timberline
<p>http://judgephilosophies.wikispaces.com/Belisle%2C+Alex</p>
Alex Barnack - BK
n/a
Alex Lange - Rocky HS
n/a
Amanda DiDio - Timberline
Amber Amoureux - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Ann Veloso - Rocky HS
n/a
Audra Phelps - Columbia
n/a
Becky Fatzinger - Mtn Home
n/a
Becky Hoth - CapitalID
Benjamin Agre - Cleveland
Bob Crighton - Mtn Home
n/a
Borah Judge - Borah
n/a
Brad Cole - Hunger Hired
n/a
Brandi Hayes - Mtn Home
n/a
Brandon Weedon - Centennial
Brett Broek - Rocky HS
n/a
Capital Judge 2 - CapitalID
n/a
Carl Anderson - Skyview
n/a
Carrie Rose - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Cheryl Sutherland - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Christine Trouten - Mtn Home
n/a
Christine Negri - Mtn Home
n/a
Cody Griffiths - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Connor Hoffman - Boise High
n/a
Cydney Linch - CRHS
n/a
Dalton Montgomery - Weiser ID HS
n/a
Dan Kaiser - Boise High
n/a
Danny Cleaver - Boise High
n/a
Darci Peterson - Weiser ID HS
n/a
David Schorzman - Skyview
n/a
Debra Schorzman - Skyview
n/a
Derek Hart - Hunger Hired
n/a
Derek Hart - Kuna
n/a
Destiny Straub - CRHS
n/a
Devin Gardner - Hunger Hired
n/a
Donnie Drobny - Borah
n/a
Donovan DiDio - Timberline
Ellen Weygint - Mtn Home
n/a
Frank Waline - Timberline
George Christensen - Nampa
n/a
George Michael Pescaru - Timberline
Heather Hall-Dudney - CapitalID
n/a
Igor Autin - Boise High
n/a
Jane Anderson - Rocky HS
n/a
Jason Carlson - CRHS
n/a
Jeff Stoppenhagen - Nampa
n/a
Jennifer Smith - CRHS
n/a
Jennifer Johnson-Waskow - Skyview
n/a
Jerry Marsh - CRHS
n/a
Jessica Dean - Hunger Hired
n/a
Joan Miller - Centennial
John Coulthard - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Jon Stutzman - BK
n/a
Joni Carlo - Hunger Hired
n/a
Josh Bell - Hunger Hired
n/a
Kallee McGrady - Boise High
Karen Nunnally - Hunger Hired
n/a
Kat Ashcraft - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Katie Doi - Meridian
n/a
Keli Elledge - BK
n/a
Kelly Helland - Centennial
Ken Dey - Meridian
n/a
Kiley Crill - Rocky HS
n/a
Lauren Johnson - Boise High
n/a
Lee Hoalst - Hunger Hired
n/a
Leslie Litke - Rocky HS
n/a
Lisa Conn - Rocky HS
n/a
Lori Palmer - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Maria Lott - Skyview
n/a
Mark Henningfeld - Columbia
n/a
Mark Engberson - Rocky HS
n/a
Marsha Straub - CRHS
n/a
Mary Dowski - Nampa
n/a
Matt Marsh - CRHS
n/a
Meghan McDonagh - Centennial
Mia Leckie - Nampa
n/a
Michael Triolo - Nampa
n/a
Michael McDonagh - Centennial
PFD Judge2 - CapitalID
n/a
Patrick Gonzales - Cleveland
Pattina Leeper - Hunger Hired
n/a
Paul Montreuil - Centennial
<p>3 Years debating at Idaho State 1 Year at UNI<br /> 4 Years judging college debate</p> <p>8 Years judging high school debate<br /> <br /> My favorite debaters (in no particular order)- Michael Klinger, Jessica Yeats, Stephen Weil, Sunil Pai and Kade Olsen<br /> My favorite judges (in no particular order)- Steve Pointer, Mike Hester, Adam Symonds and Aimi Hamraie<br /> <br /> My favorite strategy for pretty much any argument is impact turning. You should probably do what you do best though.<br /> <br /> I’m very strict about clarity and the highlighting of evidence. If you have an off case arg or advantage that takes less than a minute to read you should probably save it for another critic.<br /> <br /> Topicality- Explanations of aff and neg ground under your interpretation goes a long way. I’m persuaded more than most by reasonability arguments.<br /> <br /> DA’s- Defense is underrated. Please highlight enough of your ev to make an actual argument. Remember what I said about impact turning.<br /> <br /> CP’s- I lean affirmative on most theory questions.<br /> <br /> K’s- The key to winning these debates, regardless of side, is to talk about the aff. Don’t assume I’ve read the same literature you have so keep the jargon to a minimum. In most K debates I’ve seen there isn’t enough discussion of the alternative for my liking.<br /> <br /> Framework- I’m one of the sick few that enjoy these arguments. A clear framework for evaluating impacts is a necessity for any argument. Whether you’re down with traditional or non-traditional frameworks you should make these arguments in front of me.<br /> <br /> I’m not sure I can be offended and I respect boldness. I’m confused by the widespread belief that people somehow have a right to not be offended.<br /> <br /> Oh and paperless teams- don't give the other team a document with cards you aren't going to read. If you realize you have to skip some cards to cover tell them exactly how many cards you are skipping then take prep (your own) to delete them from their document before the next cx starts.<br /> <br /> Good luck to all. Any questions please ask. I promise to work hard and I respect you for participating in this intense competition.</p>
Penny McClain - Skyview
n/a
Phil Phillips - Timberline
Ralph DeSimone - Skyview
n/a
Robin Jensen - Columbia
n/a
Robin Jensen - Hunger Hired
n/a
Ryan Mulvaney - Hunger Hired
n/a
Ryan Mulvaney - Kuna
n/a
Sage Rogers - Boise High
n/a
Savvy Harrod - Hunger Hired
n/a
Seth Vick - CapitalID
<p> </p> <div style="font-family: arial, sans-serif; font-size: 13px; "> Tabula Rasa (default to policy maker if you don't put me in another paradigm)</div> <div style="font-family: arial, sans-serif; font-size: 13px; "> Speed is fine, slowing down on tags is helpful for flowing</div> <div style="font-family: arial, sans-serif; font-size: 13px; "> Theory is fine, I default to competing interpretations unless you argue otherwise</div> <div style="font-family: arial, sans-serif; font-size: 13px; "> Kritiks are fine, just be prepared to do the work</div> <div style="font-family: arial, sans-serif; font-size: 13px; "> As my paradigm shows, I'm pretty much prepared to handle whatever you want to throw at me. I debated for Capital High School 05-07, and have judged constantly since then. I'm big on impact analysis, if you want me to vote for you then the best way to accomplish that is to give me the whole story about why aff advantages outweigh negative impacts or vice versa. Slow down on tag lines and citations to make sure that I get the complete idea, I don't mind if you buzz through the card as long as you're understandable. Other than that, it's your round.</div>
Steve Hudson - Mtn Home
n/a
Steve Brown - Boise High
n/a
Summer Cook - Mtn. View (ID)
n/a
Tony Rogers - Hunger Hired
n/a
Tori Emeric - Weiser ID HS
n/a
Tyra Tipple - Borah
n/a
Victoria Armstrong - Mtn Home
n/a
Wendy Kotts - Columbia
n/a