2015 Kamiak Invitational
Kamiak High School - Jan 30-31 | Status: Completed
Judge Philosophies
Alisa Liu - Interlake
Andrea Lairson - Bear Creek
Anna Kitchener - SWHS
n/a
Bob Gomulkiewiz - Bear Creek
Brent DeCracker - Cedar Park
n/a
Christina Glass - Bear Creek
n/a
Crystal Ugolini - U-High
n/a
Dain Lee - BC ACADEMY
n/a
David Jung - BC ACADEMY
n/a
Dawna Lewis - Kamiak
n/a
Derek Hanson - Kamiak
n/a
Emily Feder - Seattle Academy
n/a
Erin Vaniski - SWHS
n/a
Evan Hansen - PCCS
n/a
Francis Carhart - Bear Creek
n/a
Gina Su - PCCS
n/a
Holly Musgrave - U-High
n/a
Ian Lister - Orcas High Scho
n/a
Jacob Ball - Kamiak
n/a
Jane McCoy - ECHS
Jennifer Williams - Kamiak
n/a
Joel Underwood - Seattle Academy
n/a
John Julian - Bear Creek
n/a
Jon Fedele - Kamiak
n/a
Joseph Hyink - PCCS
n/a
Julie Carpenter - Sehome
n/a
Kaylee McElroy - Kamiak
n/a
Kelley Kirkpatrick - Mount Vernon
<p>I was formerly a policy debater... but now find myself mostly coaching Lincoln Douglas debate! I am open to any type of argument as long as it is clearly explained and well argued. Speed isn't normally an issue... and I do verballly let debaters know when I am finding them unclear. </p>
Kylie Smith - Kamiak
n/a
Laura Livingston - Sehome
n/a
Lisa Weber - Kamiak
n/a
Mary Orlosky - Cedar Park
n/a
Mike Fitzgerald - Kamiak
n/a
Mr. Pavesi - Kamiak
n/a
Peter Lukevich - Bishop Blanchet
n/a
Rachael Sherrer - Bear Creek
n/a
Rob Sorensen - Bear Creek
<p> </p> <p class="MsoNormal"> <span style="color:#1F497D">I’m a traditional judge – I consider the value/criteria debate to be most important. Your contentions should flow naturally from your VC and should be clearly and intentionally related. I’m quite skeptical of theory and kritiks, so if you want to run these, you will need also to argue convincingly as to <u>why</u> I should vote on these sorts of things. I expect debaters to actually engage the resolution, rather than trying to redefine or avoid the commonsense intention of the resolution. </span></p> <p class="MsoNormal"> <span style="color:#1F497D">Don’t try to spread. I value clarity, fluency, and eloquence and have limited tolerance for speed. I will not vote for a debater whose case I cannot easily follow and flow.<o:p></o:p></span></p>
Sarah Orlotzky - Seattle Academy
n/a
Steve McCartt - SWHS
n/a
Steve Rowe - Interlake
Susan Mohn - Interlake
Thomas Tubbs - Kamiak
n/a
Vince Lee - Interlake
Vivian Hom - Bear Creek
n/a