2011 AFA District I Quals
CSU, Northridge - Mar 5-6 | Status: Completed
Judge Philosophies
AJ Moorehead - CSULA
n/a
Aaron Weinstein - Cypress
Alan Campfield - CSUN
n/a
Alexis Gardner - CSULA
Andrew West - CSUN
n/a
Angela Gregory - Chabot College
n/a
Ben Miller - Long Beach
n/a
Brandon Anderson - Long Beach
n/a
J. Edward Stevenson - CSUN
n/a
James Debbagian - DVC
Mark Dorrough - Cypress
Matt Conrad - CSUN
n/a
Mickey Korac - CSUN
n/a
Mike Harrison - CCSF
n/a
Patrick Moe - DVC
<p>You should argue whatever you want, but never assume I know why you are arguing it until you tell me why. Continuously answer the question: "So what?!" </p> <p>The longer I do this the less impressed I am by debate jargon. After competing in and coaching both high school and college forensics (including 7 years as the Director of Forensics at DVC), I speak debate fluently, but I very much prefer English. Telling me, "Jargon, jargon, jagon therefore I win" rarely actually wins my ballot. Instead what wins my ballot is an understanding of debate with examples, precedent, narrative, delivery, and a sense of humor.</p> <p>I fully understand and appreciate line by line refutation, but in rebuttals I very much prefer story-telling and persuasion over technocratic debate. Also in rebuttals when it comes to impact calculus I am much more likely to be swayed by probabilty over magnitude than I am magnitude over probability. </p> <p>Angry and yelling debate almost never wins my ballot. </p> <p>I dislike speed--I'd prefer if you talked to me like a human being rather than like a flowing robot.</p> <p>Most important, have fun and learn. If you are not having fun and learning, stop giving up your weekends to do this.</p>